Last updated on May 1st, 2025 at 10:21 am
Have you ever thought someone truly understood you, but later realized it was fake? Covert narcissists are experts at tricking people this way. They use something called the Selective Empathy of Covert Narcissists.
This means they show just enough care to make you trust them. It’s not real concern; it’s about having control over you. They know when to act caring and when to pull away, making you doubt yourself.
Spotting these fake feelings isn’t just useful; it’s very important for keeping your emotions safe. If you can see the trick, you can stop it from affecting you.
Key Takeaways
Hidden narcissists use fake care to control feelings. They act caring to make you trust them.
True empathy means sharing feelings, but hidden narcissists only pretend to care to control you.
Notice if their kindness feels like it has conditions. Their help often comes with a catch.
Pay attention if actions don’t match words. If their kindness feels fake, trust your gut.
Hidden narcissists try to rush closeness to make you depend on them. Take time to trust people.
Spot the pattern of being nice, then mean. They switch between caring and cold to confuse you.
Good relationships don’t make you feel bad for saying no. If you feel you owe them, it’s a red flag.
Talk to trusted friends or experts if you feel tricked. You deserve real and honest connections.
Understanding Covert Narcissist’s Selective Empathy
What Is Selective Empathy?
The Intact Cognitive Empathy Paradox
Have you met someone who seems to get your feelings but doesn’t care? That’s called selective empathy. Covert narcissists can understand emotions but don’t share them. They use this skill to control situations for their own benefit.
Real empathy means feeling with others, sharing their happiness or sadness. But some people only show empathy when it helps them. This selfish use of empathy makes them focus on themselves and pushes others away.
This is why their empathy feels fake. It’s not about bonding; it’s about control. They might copy your feelings to seem close, but they have selfish reasons. You may wonder, “How can they understand me but feel so distant?” That’s the trick of selective empathy.
Deliberate Disengagement From Emotional Response
Covert narcissists don’t just lack feelings—they choose to avoid them. They decide when to act caring and when to stop. For example, they might comfort you in public but ignore you in private. This isn’t random; it’s planned to keep you needing them.
Think about it: Have you ever felt confused when someone caring suddenly became cold? That’s on purpose. They know when to pull back, making you want their approval. This back-and-forth keeps you unsure of your feelings and reality.
The Psychological Architecture Of Pseudo-empathy
Calibrated Emotional Performance Versus Genuine Feeling
Covert narcissists act like actors. They pretend to feel emotions instead of actually feeling them. Their “empathy” is carefully planned to match the situation. If they need to look kind, they’ll act the part. But deep down, they don’t truly care.
Studies show narcissists feel emotions but often hide them. They think about feelings without really connecting to them. This creates a “cold empathy” that’s more about control than connection. It’s like they’re following a script, not living it.
Situational Activation Of Empathic Responses
Their empathy isn’t always there—it depends on the situation. Covert narcissists show empathy only when it benefits them. For example, they might act caring during a crisis to gain trust but disappear later. This makes their empathy seem unreliable.
Narcissists may act nice to please people or become passive-aggressive, causing problems in relationships.
They use their knowledge of emotions to control others, not to connect.
This kind of empathy can leave you feeling confused or guilty. You might think, “Did I do something wrong?” But their empathy isn’t about you—it’s all about them.
The Two Sides Of Covert Narcissistic Empathy
Public And Private Empathy Differences
Acting Kind For An Audience
Have you seen someone act caring in public but cold in private? Covert narcissists are good at this. In public, they pretend to care to impress others. They might comfort someone or say nice things to seem kind. But this act isn’t for you—it’s for the people watching.
Their kindness depends on who’s around. With strangers, they try hard to look caring. This helps them seem like a good person. But when no one is watching, their kindness disappears. You might feel hurt or wonder if you did something wrong. This change isn’t random—it’s planned to keep control.
Losing Empathy In Close Relationships
When no one is watching, their caring act stops. In private, covert narcissists often ignore your feelings. They might avoid talking about emotions or dismiss your concerns. Why? Because being kind in private doesn’t help them. Without an audience, they don’t see a reason to care.
This lack of empathy can make you feel lonely. You might ask, “Why do they care about others but not me?” The truth is, their kindness is fake. It’s a way to control, not connect. Knowing this can help you protect your feelings.
Using Empathy As A Tool
Showing Care At The Right Time
Covert narcissists don’t just fake kindness—they plan when to show it. They know when to act caring to get what they want. For example, if they think you’re pulling away, they might suddenly act nice. This isn’t real care; it’s a trick to keep you close.
They show kindness when it helps them. If they feel they’re losing control, they’ll act caring to fix it. Their kindness feels fake, like they’re following a script. At first, it might feel comforting, but over time, you’ll see the pattern: they only care when it benefits them.
Kindness As A Trade
For covert narcissists, kindness isn’t about connection—it’s a deal. They use it to gain trust or admiration. Think of it like a trade: they act kind, but only if they get something back. This could be attention or approval.
Here’s the tricky part: their kindness can seem real. They’ve learned how to copy emotions and make it look convincing. But if you pay attention, you’ll notice small mistakes. Their kindness might feel fake or lack real emotion. These little signs show their true intentions.
What They Do | What It Means |
|---|---|
They fake kindness, but their real feelings show through. | |
Act kind when they feel threatened. | They use kindness to stay in control or get what they want. |
Think about emotions instead of feeling them. | Their kindness feels cold and planned, not real. |
Learn how to act kind for different people. | They change their behavior to get the most benefit. |
Understanding this can help you see through their act. If their kindness feels fake, trust your gut. Watch for patterns and protect yourself.
Manipulation Tactics Using Selective Empathy
Copying Feelings To Fake Closeness
Planned Copying Of Emotional Signals
Have you ever thought someone really understood you, but later felt tricked? Covert narcissists are great at copying emotions. They watch how you feel, act, and talk, then mimic it. This planned copying makes you think you’re alike. You might say, “We’re so similar!” But they’re just pretending to gain your trust.
This isn’t random. Covert narcissists do this to make you feel special. For example, if you share a story, they might tell a similar one, even if it’s made up. They want you to believe they’re emotionally connected to you. But here’s the truth: they’re not trying to bond—they’re trying to control. By copying your feelings, they create a fake connection that only benefits them.
Did you know? Studies show that narcissistic copying can cause unhealthy attachments. People often feel close to the narcissist, even in harmful relationships.
Rushing Emotional Connections
After copying your emotions, covert narcissists often speed up the relationship. They might share deep stories or strong feelings early on. This makes you feel like you’ve found someone special. This trick, called rushing emotional connections, lowers your guard. You trust them before really knowing them.
Think about it: Have you ever felt a relationship moved too fast but didn’t know why? That’s this tactic at work. By faking closeness, they make you rely on them. Over time, this can trap you, especially when they switch from kind to distant.
Covert narcissists fake closeness to make you depend on them.
They copy your feelings to seem similar to you.
This trick creates a false bond, making it hard to leave.
Stealing Parts Of Your Identity
Taking Your Values And Interests
Covert narcissists don’t just copy feelings—they also take your interests. At first, it might seem nice. You might think, “They like what I like!” But soon, you’ll see a pattern. They don’t care about your hobbies; they just want to fit in and gain your trust.
For example, if you love a hobby, they might suddenly act like an expert. They use this shared interest to get closer to you. But once they have your trust, their interest fades. This isn’t about a real connection; it’s about control. By pretending to share your values, they make you feel like a team, even though they have selfish goals.
Note: Research shows covert narcissists can change your values over time. You might feel lost or unsure about who you are.
Faking Shared Beliefs
Another trick covert narcissists use is pretending to share your beliefs. They’ll agree with your opinions, copy your habits, and act like they see the world as you do. This fake agreement makes you feel understood. But later, you’ll notice they weren’t being honest. They only pretended to agree to gain your trust.
This can be very confusing. You might start doubting your own beliefs, especially if they begin to question or mock them. Over time, their influence can make you lose confidence in yourself, giving them more control.
Victims often feel their identity slowly changes to match the narcissist’s.
Constant questioning and teasing make people doubt themselves.
Important parts of the victim’s identity may shift, causing confusion.
Spotting these tricks is key to protecting yourself. If someone seems too perfect, trust your gut. Real connections take time and don’t rely on tricks or lies.
Exploiting Vulnerabilities Through Selective Empathy
Emotional Investment Extraction Tactics
Creating Psychological Debt Through Selective Support
Have you ever felt someone’s help came with strings attached? Covert narcissists are skilled at this trick. They use selective empathy to make you feel like you owe them. Their support isn’t real kindness—it’s a plan to control you.
For example, they might help you during a hard time. At first, it feels nice and comforting. Later, they remind you of their “help” to make you feel guilty. This guilt stops you from setting boundaries or focusing on yourself. This is called psychological debt, and it keeps you tied to them.
Tip: If someone’s help makes you feel guilty, it’s a warning sign. Healthy relationships don’t make you feel like you owe them for their support.
Vulnerability Mining For Future Exploitation
Covert narcissists are good at getting you to share personal things. They ask deep questions and seem to care about your struggles. But they’re not trying to help—they’re collecting your weaknesses to use later.
Imagine telling them a fear or insecurity, only for them to use it against you. During an argument, they might say, “No wonder you can’t handle anything!” This hurts and makes you feel small. It’s their way of keeping control over you.
Covert narcissists use emotions to confuse and control.
They make you feel guilty for setting boundaries.
By acting like victims, they make you feel responsible for their feelings.
The Withdrawal-reward Pattern
Strategic Empathic Withholding
Have you noticed someone pulling away when you need them most? Covert narcissists do this on purpose. They stop showing empathy to punish or control you. For example, if you call out their behavior, they might act cold and distant, leaving you feeling alone.
This isn’t random—it’s a plan. By ignoring your needs, they make you feel desperate for their attention. You start blaming yourself and chasing their approval, which is exactly what they want.
Intermittent Reinforcement Of Emotional Validation
Here’s where it gets even harder. After ignoring you, they suddenly act kind and caring again. This back-and-forth pattern is called intermittent reinforcement. It’s like a game where you never know when the next “reward” will come.
This creates a strong emotional bond. You hold onto the rare moments of kindness, even if they’re not often. Over time, this cycle lowers your self-esteem and makes it harder to leave.
Evidence Type | Description |
|---|---|
Narcissists show stronger reactions to rewards than losses, showing they value positive outcomes more. | |
N2 Response | Narcissists feel more conflict when distrusting others, showing they struggle with trust decisions. |
Note: This isn’t your fault. It’s a planned tactic to keep you emotionally stuck. Seeing the pattern is the first step to breaking free.
Using Pseudo-empathy To Disarm And Control
How Covert Narcissists Use Selective Empathy To Manipulate
The Illusion Of Emotional Safety
Have you ever felt safe with someone, then later betrayed? Covert narcissists are skilled at creating this feeling. They use selective empathy to make you feel understood. At first, they listen closely, nod, and share stories to gain trust. But this emotional safety isn’t real.
Their empathy often feels strange or fake. For example, their words might sound kind, but their actions—like avoiding eye contact or stiff movements—don’t match. This mismatch shows their true goal. They’re not helping you; they’re learning your weaknesses. Later, they’ll use what they know to control you.
Tip: Watch if someone’s actions don’t match their words. If their kindness feels planned or fake, it’s a warning sign.
Creating Dependency Through Intermittent Validation
Covert narcissists keep you emotionally hooked by switching between caring and cold. One day, they might praise you or comfort you. The next, they act distant or ignore you, leaving you confused and wanting their approval.
This back-and-forth creates a cycle. You start chasing their rare moments of kindness, hoping for the “good” version of them. Over time, this pattern lowers your confidence and makes you doubt yourself. It’s not random—it’s a plan to keep you dependent.
They make their help seem like a favor you owe them.
They use your emotional ups and downs to keep control.
Their kindness feels like a reward, not a real connection.
Why Selective Empathy Is A Key Tool For Emotional Exploitation
Weaponizing Intimacy Against Victims
Covert narcissists don’t just fake care—they use it as a weapon. By pretending to care, they get you to share personal thoughts and feelings. Later, they twist your words or use your secrets to hurt you. For example, during a fight, they might bring up something private you told them to make you feel bad.
This trick is very harmful. It can make you afraid to trust others, even in good relationships. You might feel like sharing emotions is dangerous, which is what they want. By making you feel alone, they keep control over you.
Did you know? Studies show covert narcissists remember your weaknesses to use them later for control.
Maintaining Power Imbalance Through Emotional Control
Selective empathy helps covert narcissists control relationships. They choose when to care and when to stop, keeping you unsure. This unpredictability gives them power and keeps you off balance.
For example, they might ignore you during a tough time, making you feel abandoned. Later, they’ll show just enough care to pull you back, making you grateful for small acts of kindness. This cycle keeps them in charge while making you dependent.
They use your need for connection to stay in control.
Their selective empathy creates confusion, hiding their manipulation.
By deciding when to care, they make the relationship about their needs.
Recognizing these tricks can help you protect yourself. If someone’s care feels like a tool instead of real kindness, trust your instincts. True empathy doesn’t come with conditions.
Recognizing Signs Of Covert Narcissist’s Fake Emotional Connection
The Discrepancy Markers In Pseudo-empathy
Words And Actions Don’t Match
Have you ever felt someone’s actions didn’t match their words? Covert narcissists often do this. They might say caring things but act cold. For example, they may say they’re worried but avoid eye contact or sound flat. This mismatch can make you feel uneasy, even if you’re unsure why.
Studies show this behavior is common. Therapists notice narcissists talk about emotions in a detached way. They might sound kind, but their stiff posture or blank face shows they don’t really care. This gap between words and actions is a big clue of fake empathy.
Observation | What It Means |
|---|---|
Shows fake emotional connection. | |
Detached tone when discussing feelings. | Hints at emotional disconnection. |
Avoids deeper talks about emotions. | Reveals lack of true engagement. |
If someone’s actions don’t match their words, trust your gut. Real empathy feels natural and consistent, not forced or fake.
Odd Timing In Emotional Reactions
Timing matters when showing care. Covert narcissists often get it wrong. They might comfort you too late or act overly concerned too soon. For example, they may offer help long after you needed it or before they even understand the problem.
These strange timings stand out over time. Real empathy happens naturally and fits the moment. But covert narcissists’ reactions feel planned and awkward, making you doubt their sincerity.
Behavioral Red Flags
Kindness With Strings Attached
Does someone’s kindness feel like it has a price? Covert narcissists often help only when it benefits them. They might support you when it’s convenient but disappear when you truly need them. This creates a pattern of selfish compassion that leaves you feeling drained.
Look for these warning signs:
They copy caring behaviors but don’t truly mean it.
Their help feels like a trade—you owe them something.
They isolate you from others, making you rely on them.
These behaviors don’t happen all at once. Covert narcissists slowly build control after you’ve grown attached. Spotting these patterns early can help you protect yourself.
Failing To Show Up When It Matters
Empathy isn’t about big gestures—it’s about being there when needed. Covert narcissists often fail at this. They might act caring in public but ignore you in private. This becomes clear in emotional moments when their lack of real care shows.
You might notice:
They seek attention, even when you’re upset.
They use guilt to make you feel bad for their feelings.
They break promises to help when you need them most.
These failures aren’t accidents. They’re part of a plan to keep you unsure and dependent. If you feel like you’re always questioning yourself, it’s time to rethink the relationship.
Tip: Watch how someone acts in different situations. Real empathy stays steady, while fake empathy changes to suit their needs.
Uncovering The Manipulation Cycle Of Pseudo-connection
Verbal Clues That Show Insincerity
Fake Compliments That Feel Empty
Have you ever felt like someone’s praise didn’t feel real? Covert narcissists use compliments to manipulate, but they lack sincerity. They might say things like, “You’re so brave,” or “I admire your strength,” but their tone feels cold. It’s like they’re saying words they don’t mean, just to keep you close.
At first, these comments might seem nice. But over time, you’ll notice they’re vague and lack detail. They don’t show they truly know or care about you. For example, instead of saying, “I see how hard you work,” they might say, “You’re always busy.” This small difference shows they aren’t emotionally invested.
Tip: Notice how someone praises you. If their words feel fake or shallow, trust your feelings. Real compliments are specific and heartfelt.
Caring Words Without Real Support
Covert narcissists are good at sounding caring. They’ll say things like, “I understand how you feel,” or “I’m here for you,” but their actions don’t match their words. This creates confusion because their promises of support feel empty.
For example, they might say they’ll help you but never actually do it. Or they’ll listen to your problems but quickly change the topic to themselves. This gap between what they say and do is not an accident—it’s a way to keep you dependent on them.
Note: True empathy means actions match words. If someone’s support feels one-sided, think about whether the relationship is healthy.
Long-Term Patterns Of Manipulative Empathy
Losing Care As Control Grows
At first, covert narcissists seem very caring. They’ll listen to you, give advice, and share their own stories to build trust. But as time goes on, they stop showing interest in your feelings. They might ignore your concerns or act like they don’t care anymore.
This change isn’t random. It’s a way to take control. By pulling back their care, they make you work harder for their approval. Studies show covert narcissists use fake empathy to get what they want. Over time, this leaves you feeling lonely and unsure of yourself.
Switching Between Kindness And Neglect
One of the hardest parts of dealing with a covert narcissist is their cycle of being kind and then distant. At first, they’ll give you lots of attention, compliments, and kindness. It feels like they really care about you. But this doesn’t last.
Once they’ve gained your trust, they’ll start ignoring you or acting cold. This makes you miss the connection you had before. When you try to pull away, they’ll suddenly be kind again, starting the cycle over. This back-and-forth keeps you confused and makes it hard to see their manipulation.
Did you know? Covert narcissists often act humble to test how you react. This helps them stay in control and shape how you see the relationship.
By learning these patterns, you can begin to break free. Spotting fake empathy and manipulation is the first step to protecting your emotions.
Conclusion
Selective empathy isn’t just a small habit—it’s a planned trick. Covert narcissists use it to control others. They decide when to act caring and when to stop. This leaves you confused about your own emotions. Their goal isn’t connection; it’s control.
Noticing these behaviors is the first step to staying safe. Think about how their actions make you feel. Does their kindness feel like it has a price? Do they only care when it helps them? Trust your feelings—they’re often right.
If you’re facing this, don’t be afraid to get help. Talk to someone you trust, like a friend, family member, or therapist. You deserve relationships with real care, not tricks. True empathy feels steady and safe, not confusing or fake. Stay alert, stay strong, and always protect your feelings.
Transform your Inner Chaos into authentic personal growth!
Stay informed on the latest research advancements covering:
Co-Parenting With A Narcissist
Frequently Asked Questions
Can covert narcissists feel real empathy?
They understand feelings (cognitive empathy) but don’t truly share them (emotional empathy). Their care is often planned and fake. For instance, they might comfort you in front of others but ignore you when alone. It’s about control, not real connection.
Why do covert narcissists sometimes act kind?
Their kindness is usually fake and used as a trick. They act caring only when it helps them, like gaining trust or avoiding problems. If their kindness feels fake or changes often, it’s likely part of their plan to manipulate.
How can I tell if someone’s empathy isn’t real?
Watch for actions that don’t match their words. Do they say they care but act cold? Are their reactions oddly timed or over the top? Fake care often feels planned or strange. Trust your instincts if something feels wrong.
Why do I feel bad around a covert narcissist?
Covert narcissists make you feel like you owe them by giving selective help. They do just enough to make you feel guilty. This guilt keeps you tied to them and stops you from setting limits. Healthy relationships don’t make you feel this way.
Can covert narcissists change how they act?
Change is rare unless they get professional help. Covert narcissists often don’t realize their behavior is harmful. Therapy can help, but only if they admit their actions and want to improve. You can’t make someone change.
How can I protect myself from a covert narcissist?
Set clear rules for how you want to be treated. Don’t let their fake care confuse you. Pay attention to what they do, not what they say. If their actions hurt you, talk to a therapist or a trusted friend. You deserve real, healthy relationships.
Is it my fault if I fall for their tricks?
No, it’s not your fault. Covert narcissists are very good at pretending to care and building fake trust. Their tricks are meant to confuse and control you. Seeing through their behavior is a big step in protecting yourself. Remember, their actions show who they are, not who you are.