google.com, pub-5415575505102445, DIRECT, f08c47fec0942fa0
Avatar photoSom Dutt
Publish Date

15 Subtle Signs You’re Dating A Narcissist

A Complete Guide On Narcissist Behavior

The Covert Narcissist in Romantic Relationships: Red Flags to Watch For-By Som Dutt from https://embraceinnerchaos.com

Last updated on September 2nd, 2024 at 08:26 pm

Navigating the world of dating can be thrilling, but it’s not without its challenges. Among the myriad of potential partners, some may harbor traits that can lead to toxic relationships. One particularly insidious personality type to watch out for is the narcissist. While overt signs of narcissism can be glaring, there are often more subtle indicators that can fly under the radar.

Narcissistic personality disorder (NPD) affects approximately 1% of the general population, according to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5). However, many individuals may display narcissistic traits without meeting the full criteria for NPD. These traits can significantly impact relationships, often leaving partners feeling confused, devalued, and emotionally drained.

While it’s easy to spot a narcissist who constantly boasts about their achievements or demands constant attention, some narcissistic behaviors are more nuanced. These subtle signs can be just as damaging, if not more so, because they’re often disguised as charming quirks or even expressions of love.

Understanding these less obvious indicators is crucial for protecting your emotional well-being and maintaining healthy relationships. It’s important to note that while everyone may display some narcissistic tendencies from time to time, a pattern of these behaviors can be a red flag.

In this article, we’ll explore 15 subtle signs that you might be dating a narcissist. From the initial love bombing phase to more insidious manipulation tactics like gaslighting, we’ll uncover the hidden indicators that your partner may have narcissistic tendencies.

By recognizing these signs early on, you can make informed decisions about your relationship and protect yourself from potential emotional harm. Remember, knowledge is power, and understanding the subtle manifestations of narcissism can be your first line of defense in maintaining healthy, balanced relationships.

So, let’s dive into the world of narcissistic behavior and unmask the hidden red flags that might be waving right in front of you. Whether you’re currently in a relationship or navigating the dating scene, this guide will equip you with the insights needed to identify and address narcissistic traits in your romantic partnerships.

The Emotional Toll of Narcissistic Abuse

Falling prey to narcissistic abuse can be an emotionally devastating experience. The callous exploitation victims endure often results in a constellation of painful symptoms:

  • Depression that clouds your days with hopelessness
  • Anxiety that leaves you constantly on edge
  • Hypervigilance – always waiting for the other shoe to drop
  • Toxic shame that eats away at your self-worth
  • Emotional flashbacks that bring the pain rushing back
  • Intrusive thoughts that won’t leave you alone
  • Avoidance behaviors as you try to protect yourself
  • Profound loneliness, even when surrounded by others
  • Extreme alertness, unable to ever fully relax

The aftermath of narcissistic abuse often leads people to isolate themselves due to a deep mistrust of others and fear of further harm. As author Tracy Malone poignantly states:

“She used all of her skills to charm me. I now know this was narcissistic charm and just a tactic of abuse.”

This quote perfectly encapsulates how a narcissist’s initial charm is simply a manipulative tactic, setting the stage for future abuse. The emotional toll can be overwhelming, but recognizing the signs is the first step towards healing and reclaiming your life.

15 Subtle Signs You're Dating A Narcissist
-By Som Dutt from https://embraceinnerchaos.com
15 Subtle Signs You’re Dating A Narcissist -By Som Dutt from https://embraceinnerchaos.com

Unmasking the Subtle Signs

1. Grandiosity and Sense of Entitlement

One of the hallmark traits of narcissists is their inflated sense of self-importance and abilities. This grandiose perception of reality causes them to overestimate their achievements and talents while simultaneously devaluing those around them. As Sylvia Plath astutely observed:

“I think writers are the most narcissistic people. Well, I musn’t say this, I like many of them, a great many of my friends are writers.”

This quote highlights how even talented individuals can fall prey to narcissistic tendencies, elevating themselves above others. In a relationship, this grandiosity manifests as an expectation of special treatment and constant praise. Your partner may demand that you cater to their every whim, making sacrifices for their happiness at the expense of your own needs and desires.

The sense of entitlement that accompanies grandiosity can create significant barriers to forming healthy relationships. Your narcissistic partner may expect preferential treatment in all aspects of life – at work, social events, and especially within your relationship. They become easily offended when not granted the adoration and special considerations they believe they deserve.

15 Subtle Signs You're Dating A Narcissist
-By Som Dutt from https://embraceinnerchaos.com
15 Subtle Signs You’re Dating A Narcissist -By Som Dutt from https://embraceinnerchaos.com

2. Lack of Empathy

Perhaps one of the most emotionally damaging aspects of dating a narcissist is their profound lack of empathy. This deficit in emotional intelligence makes it nearly impossible for them to truly understand or care about your feelings. As author George K. Simon Jr. explains:

“Playing the victim role: Manipulator portrays him- or herself as a victim of circumstance or of someone else’s behavior in order to gain pity, sympathy or evoke compassion and thereby get something from another. Caring and conscientious people cannot stand to see anyone suffering and the manipulator often finds it easy to play on sympathy to get cooperation.”

This quote perfectly illustrates how narcissists exploit the empathy of others while being incapable of genuine care themselves. In your relationship, this lack of empathy may manifest in various painful ways:

  • Dismissing your feelings as unimportant or irrational
  • Trivializing your experiences and struggles
  • Making you feel invalidated and unheard
  • Turning conversations back to focus on themselves
  • Showing little concern for your well-being or emotions

In more severe cases, this emotional disconnect can escalate to blatant emotional abuse. You may find yourself constantly walking on eggshells, afraid to express your true feelings for fear of their dismissive or angry reaction.

15 Subtle Signs You're Dating A Narcissist
-By Som Dutt from https://embraceinnerchaos.com
15 Subtle Signs You’re Dating A Narcissist -By Som Dutt from https://embraceinnerchaos.com

3. Love Bombing

One of the most insidious tactics employed by narcissists is love bombing. This overwhelming display of affection and attention at the beginning of a relationship is designed to quickly create a strong emotional bond. As Kurt Cobain cynically noted:

“I don’t care what you think unless it is about me.”

This quote captures the narcissist’s singular focus on themselves, even when showering you with apparent affection. The love bombing phase may include:

  • Excessive compliments and flattery
  • Lavish gifts and grand romantic gestures
  • Constant communication and desire for your attention
  • Declarations of love and commitment very early on
  • Pressure to quickly advance the relationship

While this whirlwind romance may feel intoxicating at first, it’s crucial to recognize it as a manipulation tactic. The narcissist is not genuinely interested in you as a person, but rather in securing your adoration and commitment. Once they feel they’ve “hooked” you, the mask begins to slip, revealing their true nature.

4. Gaslighting

Gaslighting is perhaps one of the most psychologically damaging behaviors exhibited by narcissists. This form of emotional manipulation causes you to question your own reality, memories, and perceptions. As Michael Bassey Johnson warns:

“Stay away from lazy parasites, who perch on you just to satisfy their needs, they do not come to alleviate your burdens, hence, their mission is to distract, detract and extract, and make you live in abject poverty.”

This quote vividly illustrates how gaslighting narcissists feed off your emotional energy while leaving you depleted and confused. Some common gaslighting tactics include:

  • Denying events or conversations that you clearly remember
  • Telling you that you’re “too sensitive” or “overreacting”
  • Twisting facts to fit their narrative
  • Accusing you of being paranoid or crazy for questioning them
  • Withholding information to maintain control

The cumulative effect of gaslighting can be devastating, eroding your sense of self and making you dependent on the narcissist for validation of your experiences. It’s a subtle yet powerful form of emotional abuse that can leave lasting psychological scars.

5. Insatiable Need for Validation

Narcissists have an endless appetite for admiration and validation from others. This need stems from their fragile sense of self-worth, which requires constant external reinforcement. As Bertrand Russell insightfully noted:

“These illustrations suggest four general maxims[…]. The first is: remember that your motives are not always as altruistic as they seem to yourself. The second is: don’t over-estimate your own merits. The third is: don’t expect others to take as much interest in you as you do yourself. And the fourth is: don’t imagine that most people give enough thought to you to have any special desire to persecute you.”

This quote perfectly encapsulates the narcissist’s distorted view of themselves and their place in the world. In your relationship, their need for validation may manifest as:

  • Constantly seeking compliments and praise
  • Becoming upset or angry when not the center of attention
  • Exaggerating their accomplishments and talents
  • Fishing for compliments or reassurance
  • Becoming defensive or hostile when criticized

This insatiable hunger for admiration can be exhausting for their partners, who may feel like they can never provide enough validation to satisfy the narcissist’s ego.

6. Blaming Others for Their Problems

A hallmark of narcissistic behavior is an inability to take responsibility for their own actions and mistakes. Instead, they consistently shift blame onto others, including their partners. As Tracy Malone astutely observes:

“If you hold onto hurt and anger with a narcissist, the children will have no normal parent. The narcissistic parent will use them as puppets, lovebomb and abandon them. You are their only hope.”

This quote highlights the far-reaching consequences of a narcissist’s blame-shifting, especially in family dynamics. In your relationship, you may notice:

  • Your partner never admitting fault, even for small mistakes
  • Constantly blaming you for problems in the relationship
  • Making excuses for their behavior rather than apologizing
  • Accusing you of being “too sensitive” when you express hurt
  • Turning arguments around to make themselves the victim

This refusal to take responsibility creates a toxic dynamic where you may find yourself constantly apologizing and walking on eggshells to avoid triggering their blame-shifting behavior.

7. Overestimation of Their Abilities

Narcissists tend to have an inflated view of their own capabilities, often believing they are exceptional or even infallible in various areas of life. As Nassim Nicholas Taleb wryly notes:

“true humility is when you can surprise yourself more than others; the rest is either shyness or good marketing”

This quote perfectly captures the narcissist’s lack of genuine humility and their tendency to overestimate themselves. In your relationship, you may observe:

  • Your partner claiming expertise in areas where they have little knowledge
  • Dismissing the opinions or advice of actual experts
  • Becoming defensive or angry when their abilities are questioned
  • Taking on projects or responsibilities beyond their skill level
  • Blaming others or external factors when they fail

This overconfidence can lead to reckless decision-making and a refusal to learn from mistakes, creating stress and instability in both personal and professional spheres.

15 Subtle Signs You're Dating A Narcissist
-By Som Dutt from https://embraceinnerchaos.com
15 Subtle Signs You’re Dating A Narcissist -By Som Dutt from https://embraceinnerchaos.com

8. Taking Advantage of Others

Narcissists are masters at exploiting the goodwill and resources of those around them. They view relationships primarily in terms of what they can gain, rather than as mutual partnerships. As Isaiah Hankel powerfully states:

“Don’t ever feel bad for making a decision about your own life that upsets other people. You are not responsible for their happiness. You’re responsible for your own happiness. Anyone who wants you to live in misery for their happiness should not be in your life anyway.”

This quote emphasizes the importance of setting boundaries with those who seek to take advantage of you. In a relationship with a narcissist, you may experience:

  • Your partner consistently putting their needs before yours
  • Being expected to make sacrifices while they rarely reciprocate
  • Feeling used for your resources, connections, or emotional support
  • Your kindness being taken for granted or exploited
  • Guilt-tripping when you try to establish boundaries

This pattern of exploitation can leave you feeling drained, used, and undervalued in the relationship.

9. Lack of Accountability

Closely related to their tendency to blame others, narcissists also display a striking lack of accountability for their actions. They struggle to admit mistakes or acknowledge how their behavior impacts others. As Janet M. Tavakoli pointedly observes:

“Narcissists have poor self-esteem, but they are typically very successful. They feel entitled; they’re self-important; they crave admiration and lack empathy. They are also exploitative and envious. The malignant types never forget a slight. They may kill you ten years later for cutting them off in traffic. But they act perfectly normal while plotting their revenge.”

This chilling quote highlights the potential for long-term, calculated retaliation from narcissists who feel slighted. In your relationship, a lack of accountability may manifest as:

  • Your partner never offering sincere apologies
  • Minimizing the impact of their hurtful actions
  • Becoming defensive or angry when confronted about their behavior
  • Making promises to change but never following through
  • Gaslighting you into believing you’re overreacting to their actions

This absence of accountability creates a one-sided relationship where you’re constantly managing their emotions and behavior while your own needs go unmet.

10. Obsessive Need for Control

Narcissists have an insatiable desire for control over their environment and the people in their lives. This need stems from their deep-seated insecurities and fear of abandonment. As Crystal Woods astutely notes:

“Truthfully, there’re only a handful of people in this world who really get joy from seeing you happy. Most won’t care if you’re happy, only if you’re miserable like they are. They eat that shit up.”

This quote captures the narcissist’s tendency to derive satisfaction from controlling and diminishing others. In your relationship, this control may manifest as:

  • Dictating how you should dress, act, or spend your time
  • Monitoring your communications and social media activity
  • Isolating you from friends and family
  • Making unilateral decisions about important matters
  • Using emotional manipulation to keep you in line

This suffocating control can leave you feeling trapped, constantly walking on eggshells to avoid their displeasure.

11. Difficulty Setting Boundaries

One of the most challenging aspects of being in a relationship with a narcissist is their inability to respect personal boundaries. They often view boundaries as challenges to be overcome rather than healthy limits to be respected. As Oliver Markus Malloy observes:

“I think future generations are going to look back at our time period and call this the Age of Narcissism.”

This quote highlights how pervasive narcissistic behavior has become in our society, making it even more crucial to establish and maintain strong boundaries. In your relationship, you may struggle with:

  • Your partner consistently overstepping your stated limits
  • Feeling guilty or selfish for trying to enforce boundaries
  • Being accused of not loving them enough when you set limits
  • Your partner using emotional manipulation to erode your boundaries
  • Constantly feeling like your personal space and autonomy are violated

The narcissist’s disregard for boundaries can leave you feeling overwhelmed, violated, and unsure of where you end and they begin.

12. Lack of Genuine Interest in Others

While narcissists may appear charming and attentive at first, their interest in others is typically shallow and self-serving. They struggle to engage in genuine, reciprocal relationships. As John Steinbeck keenly observed:

“For the most part people are not curious except about themselves.”

This quote perfectly captures the narcissist’s self-centered worldview. In your relationship, you may notice:

  • Conversations always steering back to your partner
  • A lack of curiosity about your thoughts, feelings, or experiences
  • Your partner zoning out when you talk about yourself
  • Feeling like you don’t truly know your partner on a deep level
  • A sense that your partner sees you as an extension of themselves rather than an individual

This lack of genuine interest can leave you feeling lonely and unfulfilled, even when in the narcissist’s presence.

13. Emotional Volatility

Narcissists often struggle with emotional regulation, leading to dramatic mood swings and intense reactions. Their fragile ego makes them highly sensitive to perceived slights or criticism. As Karen Kilgariff pointedly notes:

“Have you always felt unseen, ignored, or unloved? Congratulations! You’re the perfect prey for narcissists who feed off of blind worship and internal sadness. You’ll never convince the target of your obsession that your love is what Sade was singing about on that one album. But oh, you will try. And in doing so, you will damage your self esteem. And then, once you will wake up from the stupid spell you put on yourself, you can rail against those narcissists, but it won’t affect them. So it’s better just to skip ahead to the part where you admit that you’re the one who bought the ticket to their show. Choose to want to figure out why you do these things and how to stop. In the end, it’s all you can do.”

This insightful quote highlights how narcissists prey on those with low self-esteem, creating a cycle of emotional turmoil. In your relationship, you may experience:

  • Sudden outbursts of anger over minor issues
  • Intense jealousy and possessiveness
  • Rapid shifts between idealization and devaluation
  • Emotional withdrawal as a form of punishment
  • Dramatic reactions to perceived slights or lack of attention

This emotional rollercoaster can leave you feeling constantly on edge, never knowing what might trigger the next outburst.

15 Subtle Signs You're Dating A Narcissist
-By Som Dutt from https://embraceinnerchaos.com
15 Subtle Signs You’re Dating A Narcissist -By Som Dutt from https://embraceinnerchaos.com

14. Inability to Handle Criticism

Narcissists have an extremely fragile ego beneath their grandiose exterior. As a result, they struggle to handle even constructive criticism without becoming defensive or lashing out. As Erich Fromm insightfully states:

“The faculty to think objectively is reason; the emotional attitude behind reason is that of humility. To be objective, to use one’s reason, is possible only if one has achieved an attitude of humility, if one has emerged from the dreams of omniscience and omnipotence which one has as a child. Love, being dependent on the relative absence of narcissism, requires the developement of humility, objectivity and reason. I must try to see the difference between my picture of a person and his behavior, as it is narcissistically distorted, and the person’s reality as it exists regardless of my interests, needs and fears.”

This quote beautifully illustrates the connection between humility, objectivity, and the ability to love truly. In contrast, a narcissistic partner may:

  • Become angry or defensive when you offer feedback
  • Turn criticisms around on you, attacking your character
  • Dismiss your concerns as invalid or unimportant
  • Use guilt or manipulation to avoid addressing issues
  • Punish you emotionally for daring to criticize them

15. Superficial Charm and Charisma

The final subtle sign of dating a narcissist is their superficial charm and charisma. While this may seem positive at first, it’s often a carefully crafted facade designed to manipulate and control. As Tracy Malone astutely observes:

“Narcissists hate to get rained on because it ruins the mask.”

This quote vividly illustrates how the narcissist’s charm is merely a mask, easily disrupted when challenged. In your relationship, you may notice:

  • Your partner being exceptionally charming in public but cold in private
  • A disconnect between their words and actions
  • Using their charm to manipulate situations in their favor
  • An ability to quickly win people over, only to discard them later
  • A sense that their affection is conditional on your compliance

This superficial charm can make it difficult to recognize the narcissist’s true nature, especially in the early stages of the relationship.

Identifying Narcissism: Trusting Your Instincts

Recognizing the signs of narcissism in a partner can be challenging, especially when clouded by emotions and manipulation. However, spotting these red flags is crucial for protecting your emotional well-being. Here are some strategies for identifying narcissistic behavior:

Trust Your Gut Instincts

Often, our intuition picks up on subtle cues that our conscious mind might overlook. As Munia Khan wisely notes:

“In a world of selfie-addiction smile usually is the brand name for an essential drug called pretense”

This quote highlights how appearances can be deceiving, especially in the age of social media. When dating a narcissist, you may experience:

  • A nagging feeling that something isn’t quite right
  • Confusion about why you feel anxious or on edge around your partner
  • A sense of emotional exhaustion after spending time together
  • Doubting your own perceptions due to gaslighting

Learning to trust these instincts is crucial for recognizing narcissistic behavior early on.

Observe Their Behavior Patterns

While narcissists can be charming and manipulative, consistent observation of their behavior often reveals their true nature. Pay attention to:

  • How they treat service workers or people they perceive as “beneath” them
  • Their reactions when they don’t get their way
  • How they handle criticism or challenges to their authority
  • The consistency (or lack thereof) between their words and actions
  • Their level of empathy and concern for others’ feelings

Recognizing these telltale traits can help you identify narcissistic tendencies before becoming too emotionally invested.

Seek Outside Perspectives

When caught in the web of a narcissistic relationship, it can be difficult to see the situation clearly. Seeking input from trusted friends, family members, or a therapist can provide valuable outside perspectives. They may notice signs you’re dealing with a narcissist that you’ve overlooked or rationalized.

The Harmful Effects of Dating a Narcissist

Engaging in a relationship with a narcissist can have severe and long-lasting impacts on your mental health and well-being. Understanding these effects is crucial for recognizing the seriousness of the situation and motivating yourself to seek help.

Decreased Self-Esteem

One of the most insidious effects of dating a narcissist is the gradual erosion of your self-esteem. The constant criticism, manipulation, and emotional abuse can leave you feeling worthless and undeserving of love. As Karen Kilgariff poignantly observes:

“Have you always felt unseen, ignored, or unloved? Congratulations! You’re the perfect prey for narcissists who feed off of blind worship and internal sadness.”

This quote highlights how narcissists target individuals with already fragile self-esteem, exacerbating existing insecurities.

Anxiety and Depression

The emotional rollercoaster of dating a narcissist often leads to increased anxiety and depression. The constant uncertainty, walking on eggshells, and feelings of inadequacy can take a severe toll on your mental health. You may experience:

  • Persistent worry about your partner’s mood or reactions
  • Feelings of hopelessness about the future of the relationship
  • Loss of interest in activities you once enjoyed
  • Physical symptoms like changes in appetite or sleep patterns
  • Difficulty concentrating or making decisions

Difficulty Setting Boundaries

Narcissists are notorious for pushing and violating boundaries. Over time, this can erode your ability to set and maintain healthy limits in all areas of your life. As Tracy Malone wisely advises:

“Boundaries are guidelines, rules and limits we all must set to protect our time, heart, finances, etc. Without strong defined boundaries we expose ourselves to being abused by narcissists.”

This quote underscores the importance of maintaining strong boundaries as a form of self-protection.

Trust Issues

The manipulation, lies, and gaslighting that often accompany narcissistic relationships can severely damage your ability to trust others. This can impact not only future romantic relationships but also friendships and professional connections. You may find yourself:

  • Constantly questioning others’ motives
  • Struggling to open up emotionally
  • Overanalyzing every interaction for signs of deception
  • Fearing vulnerability and intimacy

Codependency

Many individuals in relationships with narcissists develop codependent behaviors as a coping mechanism. This unhealthy dynamic can leave you feeling responsible for your partner’s emotions and actions, neglecting your own needs in the process. Signs of codependency may include:

  • Prioritizing your partner’s needs over your own
  • Difficulty making decisions without your partner’s input
  • Feeling responsible for your partner’s happiness
  • Sacrificing your own values or beliefs to please your partner
  • Struggling to identify your own emotions and needs

Coping Mechanisms and Healing Strategies

Recognizing that you’re in a relationship with a narcissist is the first step towards healing. Here are some strategies for coping with the situation and beginning the journey of recovery:

Setting Personal Boundaries

Establishing and maintaining firm boundaries is crucial when dealing with a narcissistic partner. This may involve:

  • Clearly communicating your limits and expectations
  • Consistently enforcing consequences when boundaries are violated
  • Prioritizing your own needs and well-being
  • Learning to say “no” without guilt or fear

Practicing Self-Care

Engaging in regular self-care is essential for maintaining your mental and emotional health. This can include:

  • Engaging in activities that bring you joy and fulfillment
  • Maintaining connections with supportive friends and family
  • Prioritizing physical health through exercise and proper nutrition
  • Practicing mindfulness or meditation to manage stress

Seeking Professional Help

Working with a therapist who specializes in narcissistic abuse can provide invaluable support and guidance. They can help you:

  • Process the trauma of the relationship
  • Rebuild your self-esteem and sense of identity
  • Develop healthy coping mechanisms
  • Navigate the process of leaving the relationship, if you choose to do so

Educating Yourself

Learning more about narcissistic personality disorder and its effects can be empowering. It can help you:

  • Understand that you’re not alone in your experiences
  • Recognize overlooked red flags of narcissism in future relationships
  • Develop strategies for protecting yourself from narcissistic abuse

Connecting with Support Groups

Joining support groups for survivors of narcissistic abuse can provide a sense of community and understanding. These groups offer:

  • A safe space to share your experiences
  • Validation of your feelings and experiences
  • Practical advice from others who have been in similar situations
  • A reminder that recovery is possible

Moving Forward: Reclaiming Your Life

Recovering from a relationship with a narcissist is a journey, not a destination. It requires patience, self-compassion, and a commitment to your own healing. As you move forward, remember:

By recognizing the subtle signs you’re dating a narcissist and taking steps to protect yourself, you’re already on the path to reclaiming your life and building healthier, more fulfilling relationships.

Remember, as you navigate this challenging journey, you’re not alone. There are resources, support systems, and professionals ready to help you every step of the way. Your well-being and happiness matter, and with time and effort, you can heal from the effects of narcissistic abuse and create the life you deserve.

About the Author :

Som Dutt, Top writer in Philosophy & Psychology on Medium.com. I make people Think, Relate, Feel & Move. Let's Embrace Inner Chaos and Appreciate Deep, Novel & Heavy Thoughts.

2 comments On 15 Subtle Signs You’re Dating A Narcissist

  • I just enjoyed reading this article. Thank you for this insightful article! It’s important to be aware of the subtle signs that may indicate we’re dating a narcissist. Recognizing these traits early on can help protect our emotional well-being and make more informed decisions in relationships.

    The examples provided were helpful and shed light on the manipulative tactics narcissists often employ. It would be beneficial to include some advice on how to confront and address these behaviors if encountered. Overall, I appreciate the awareness this article brings and its potential to empower individuals in their dating lives.

    The information provided is highly valuable and eye-opening. It would be even more helpful if you could expand on the section that discusses the impact of dating a narcissist on one’s self-esteem and mental health

Leave a reply:

Your email address will not be published.