google.com, pub-5415575505102445, DIRECT, f08c47fec0942fa0 Impact-Site-Verification: 41d1d5bc-3932-4474-aa09-f8236abb0433
9040696396
Avatar photoSom Dutt
Publish Date

Unmasking the Covert Narcissist: Tactics They Use to Manipulate You

How To Recognize And Counter Covert Narcissistic Manipulation

Understanding Eating Disorders: Types, Signs, And Treatment by Som Dutt From https://embraceinnerchaos.com

Last updated on December 11th, 2024 at 03:32 am

Imagine a world where your closest confidant, your partner, or even your boss is quietly pulling the strings of your emotions, leaving you feeling confused, drained, and questioning your own reality. Welcome to the hidden realm of covert narcissism – a psychological minefield that can wreak havoc on your mental well-being and relationships.

In this eye-opening exposé, we’ll delve deep into the shadowy tactics employed by covert narcissists, those master manipulators who operate beneath a veil of false humility and charm. You’ll discover how these emotional vampires subtly drain your self-esteem, gaslight your perceptions, and twist your world to suit their needs – all while maintaining a façade of innocence and victimhood.

Are you constantly walking on eggshells, feeling guilty for expressing your own needs, or doubting your own memories? These could be telltale signs that you’re entangled in a covert narcissist’s web. But fear not – knowledge is power, and understanding their playbook is the first step towards reclaiming your autonomy and emotional freedom.

Prepare to have your eyes opened as we unmask the covert narcissist and arm you with the tools to recognize, confront, and ultimately break free from their insidious influence. Your journey to emotional liberation starts here – are you ready to take back control?

1. Emotional Manipulation Tactics

1.1. Emotional Blackmail and Guilt-Tripping

Covert narcissists are masters of emotional manipulation, and one of their most potent weapons is emotional blackmail and guilt-tripping. These tactics are designed to make you feel responsible for their emotional state and manipulate you into doing what they want.

A covert narcissist might say things like, “If you really loved me, you’d do this for me,” or “After all I’ve done for you, this is how you repay me?” These statements are carefully crafted to exploit your empathy and sense of obligation.

They may also use more subtle forms of guilt-tripping, such as sighing heavily, looking disappointed, or making passive-aggressive comments. The goal is to make you feel guilty for not meeting their expectations, even if those expectations are unreasonable.

Emotional blackmail often follows a pattern:

• The narcissist makes a demand
• You resist or express hesitation
• They respond with threats (veiled or overt) of emotional consequences
• You feel pressured to comply to avoid those consequences

This cycle can be incredibly damaging, eroding your self-esteem and making you doubt your own judgement. It’s crucial to recognize these guilt-tripping tactics for what they are: manipulation, not genuine expressions of hurt or need.

Unmasking the Covert Narcissist: Tactics They Use to Manipulate You
-By Som Dutt from https://embraceinnerchaos.com
Unmasking the Covert Narcissist: Tactics They Use to Manipulate You -By Som Dutt from https://embraceinnerchaos.com

1.2. Passive-Aggressive Behavior

Passive-aggressive behavior is another hallmark of the covert narcissist’s manipulation toolbox. Unlike overt aggression, which is easy to spot and confront, passive-aggression is subtle and often leaves you feeling confused and frustrated.

Some common passive-aggressive tactics used by covert narcissists include:

• Procrastination or deliberate inefficiency
• Sulking or pouting
• Withholding praise or affection
• Making excuses or playing the victim
• Using sarcasm or backhanded compliments

For example, a covert narcissist might agree to do something for you, but then “forget” or do it poorly on purpose. Or they might give you the silent treatment instead of expressing their anger directly.

This behavior allows the narcissist to express negative feelings while maintaining plausible deniability. If confronted, they can easily deny any ill intent, leaving you feeling like you’re overreacting or imagining things.

1.3. Silent Treatment and Stonewalling

The silent treatment is a particularly insidious form of emotional abuse favored by covert narcissists. It involves completely withdrawing communication and emotional availability as a way to punish or control you.

During the silent treatment, the narcissist might:

• Refuse to speak to you or acknowledge your presence
• Ignore your calls, texts, or emails
• Avoid eye contact or physical proximity
• Act as if you don’t exist

This tactic can be incredibly distressing, triggering feelings of abandonment, confusion, and self-doubt. The narcissist knows this and uses it to their advantage, often breaking the silence only when you’ve been sufficiently “punished” or when they need something from you.

Stonewalling is a related tactic where the narcissist refuses to engage in meaningful communication, often during conflicts. They might respond with monosyllables, change the subject, or simply shut down entirely. This prevents any resolution and leaves you feeling unheard and invalidated.

1.4. Gaslighting and Reality Distortion

Gaslighting is perhaps the most psychologically damaging tactic in the covert narcissist’s arsenal. It’s a form of psychological manipulation where the narcissist attempts to sow seeds of doubt in your mind, making you question your own memory, perception, and sanity.

Common gaslighting phrases include:

• “That never happened.”
• “You’re too sensitive.”
• “You’re imagining things.”
• “You’re overreacting.”
• “I never said that.”

The covert narcissist might deny saying or doing things you clearly remember, or they might twist your words and actions to fit their narrative. They might even enlist others to support their version of events, leaving you feeling isolated and doubting your own reality.

Over time, gaslighting can erode your self-confidence and make you increasingly dependent on the narcissist for validation and a sense of reality. It’s a slow, insidious process that can be incredibly difficult to recognize when you’re in the midst of it.

1.5. Intermittent reinforcement and trauma bonding

Intermittent reinforcement is a psychological technique that covert narcissists use to keep their victims hooked. It involves unpredictably alternating between affection and cruelty, creating a powerful emotional bond known as trauma bonding.

Here’s how it works:

• The narcissist is kind and loving, making you feel special and valued
• Suddenly, they withdraw affection or become cruel
• You work hard to regain their approval
• They eventually return to being kind, providing a sense of relief and joy
• The cycle repeats

This unpredictable pattern keeps you constantly on edge, always working to please the narcissist in hopes of receiving their “good” side. It’s similar to the psychological mechanism that makes gambling addictive – the occasional “win” keeps you coming back for more, even when you’re mostly losing.

Trauma bonding occurs when this cycle creates a strong emotional attachment to the abuser. You become addicted to the highs of their occasional kindness, even as you suffer through the lows of their abuse. This bond can make it extremely difficult to leave the relationship, even when you recognize it’s unhealthy.

2. The Covert Narcissist’s Weaponization of Vulnerability

2.1. Playing the Victim Card

Covert narcissists are adept at portraying themselves as victims, a tactic that serves multiple purposes in their manipulation arsenal. By playing the victim, they can:

• Garner sympathy and attention
• Deflect responsibility for their actions
• Manipulate others into catering to their needs
• Avoid accountability

This victim mentality is often deeply ingrained and may seem genuine, even to the narcissist themselves. They might constantly complain about how unfairly life treats them, how others always let them down, or how they’re misunderstood and unappreciated.

For example, a covert narcissist might say things like:

• “Nobody understands how much I suffer.”
• “I try so hard, but nothing ever goes my way.”
• “Everyone always takes advantage of my kindness.”

By consistently portraying themselves as the victim, covert narcissists create a narrative where they’re always the wronged party. This makes it difficult for others to confront them about their behavior, as any criticism can be twisted into further “proof” of their victimhood.

2.2. False Humility and Self-Deprecation

Unlike their grandiose counterparts, covert narcissists often display false humility and engage in self-deprecating behavior. This can be confusing, as it seems to contradict the typical narcissistic trait of inflated self-importance.

However, this false humility serves several purposes:

• It masks their true sense of superiority
• It elicits praise and reassurance from others
• It creates an image of being humble and relatable

A covert narcissist might say things like:

• “Oh, I’m not that talented. You’re much better at this than I am.”
• “I’m probably too stupid to understand this.”
• “I’m sure everyone else here is more qualified than me.”

While these statements might seem like genuine expressions of insecurity, they’re often fishing for compliments or setting up a situation where others feel compelled to build them up. It’s a subtle way of demanding attention and admiration while maintaining a façade of humility.

Unmasking the Covert Narcissist: Tactics They Use to Manipulate You
-By Som Dutt from https://embraceinnerchaos.com
Unmasking the Covert Narcissist: Tactics They Use to Manipulate You -By Som Dutt from https://embraceinnerchaos.com

2.3. Covert Boasting and Humble-Bragging

Covert narcissists have a unique way of bragging that allows them to satisfy their need for admiration while maintaining their façade of humility. This often takes the form of humble-bragging or covert boasting.

Humble-bragging involves complaining about or downplaying something that is actually a boast. For example:

• “It’s so annoying when people keep asking me for advice just because I have three degrees.”
• “I hate having to turn down all these job offers. It’s so stressful!”
• “Ugh, I’m so clumsy. I just tripped over my award from last night.”

Covert boasting, on the other hand, involves subtly inserting achievements or desirable qualities into conversation without directly bragging. For instance:

• Casually mentioning high-status friends or connections
• Dropping hints about expensive purchases or exclusive experiences
• Referencing past accomplishments in seemingly unrelated contexts

These tactics allow the covert narcissist to feed their need for admiration and recognition while maintaining their image of modesty and relatability.

2.4. Self-pity and martyr complex in covert narcissism

Covert narcissists often develop a martyr complex, portraying themselves as long-suffering individuals who sacrifice everything for others. This self-pitying attitude serves several purposes:

• It elicits sympathy and attention from others
• It creates a sense of moral superiority
• It deflects criticism and accountability

A covert narcissist with a martyr complex might say things like:

• “I always put everyone else first, and what do I get in return? Nothing.”
• “No one appreciates all I do for them. I might as well not exist.”
• “I’ve given up everything for this family/job/relationship, and this is how I’m treated?”

This constant self-pity can be exhausting for those around them. It creates a dynamic where others feel guilty for not appreciating the narcissist enough, leading to a cycle of emotional manipulation.

The martyr complex also allows the covert narcissist to avoid taking responsibility for their actions or life circumstances. By framing everything as a sacrifice or unfair burden, they can maintain their self-image as a good person while avoiding the need for personal growth or change.

Unmasking the Covert Narcissist: Tactics They Use to Manipulate You
-By Som Dutt from https://embraceinnerchaos.com
Unmasking the Covert Narcissist: Tactics They Use to Manipulate You -By Som Dutt from https://embraceinnerchaos.com

3. Language and Communication Tactics

3.1. Subtle Put-Downs and Negging

Covert narcissists are masters of subtle put-downs and negging, a manipulative tactic where they give backhanded compliments or make slight criticisms to undermine your self-esteem. These comments are often delivered with a smile or a laugh, making them hard to confront without seeming overly sensitive.

Examples of subtle put-downs include:

• “You’re so brave to wear that outfit. I could never pull that off.”
• “Wow, you’re actually pretty smart for someone in your field.”
• “I’m impressed you managed to finish that project. It must have been challenging for you.”

Negging often involves comparing you unfavorably to others or highlighting your insecurities:

• “You’re almost as good at this as [someone else].”
• “You look great today. Did you lose weight?”
• “I love how you don’t care about fashion trends.”

These comments are designed to make you feel slightly insecure or inferior, while the narcissist maintains plausible deniability. If confronted, they can easily claim they meant it as a compliment or that you’re being too sensitive.

3.2. Circular Conversations and Word Salad

Covert narcissists often engage in circular conversations and use word salad to confuse and frustrate you. These tactics are particularly common during arguments or when you’re trying to address issues in the relationship.

Circular conversations involve going round and round on a topic without ever reaching a resolution. The narcissist might:

• Constantly change the subject
• Bring up unrelated issues
• Rehash old arguments
• Refuse to acknowledge your points

Word salad, on the other hand, involves using a stream of words that sound meaningful but are actually nonsensical or contradictory. This might include:

• Stringing together buzzwords or jargon
• Making vague, grandiose statements
• Using logical fallacies
• Contradicting themselves within the same sentence

The goal of these tactics is to exhaust and confuse you, making it difficult to maintain your original point or stand your ground. You might find yourself feeling frustrated, disoriented, and unsure of what was even being discussed in the first place.

3.3. Selective Memory and Convenient Forgetfulness

Covert narcissists often display selective memory, conveniently forgetting things that don’t align with their narrative or remembering events differently than they actually occurred. This tactic serves several purposes:

• It allows them to avoid accountability
• It reinforces their preferred version of reality
• It gaslights you into doubting your own memory

You might find the narcissist:

• Denying they said or did something you clearly remember
• Insisting on a different version of events
• Forgetting promises or commitments they’ve made
• Claiming you never told them something important

This selective memory can be incredibly frustrating and confusing. You might start to doubt your own recollection of events, especially if the narcissist is convincing in their alternate version of reality.

3.4. Backhanded compliments and veiled criticism

Backhanded compliments and veiled criticism are staples in the covert narcissist’s communication toolkit. These tactics allow them to undermine your confidence while maintaining a façade of kindness or helpfulness.

Backhanded compliments might sound like:

• “You’re so relaxed about your appearance. I wish I could be that carefree.”
• “Your presentation was good… for a beginner.”
• “I’m impressed you managed to cook dinner without burning anything this time.”

Veiled criticism often takes the form of “helpful” suggestions or observations:

• “Have you thought about getting a personal trainer? I’m just concerned about your health.”
• “Maybe if you put in a little more effort at work, you could get that promotion.”
• “I noticed you seemed a bit awkward at the party. I could give you some tips on socializing if you want.”

These comments are designed to make you feel insecure or inadequate while allowing the narcissist to maintain plausible deniability. If confronted, they can easily claim they were trying to be helpful or that you’re being too sensitive.

3.5. Minimizing and trivializing others’ concerns

Covert narcissists often minimize or trivialize the concerns, feelings, and experiences of others. This tactic serves to invalidate others’ perspectives and maintain the narcissist’s sense of superiority.

Common phrases used to minimize include:

• “You’re making a big deal out of nothing.”
• “It’s not that bad. You’re overreacting.”
• “There are people with real problems in the world.”

By trivializing others’ concerns, the covert narcissist:

• Deflects attention from their own behavior
• Avoids taking responsibility for their actions
• Maintains control over the narrative

This constant invalidation can be incredibly damaging to your self-esteem and emotional well-being. Over time, you might start to doubt the validity of your own feelings and experiences, making it easier for the narcissist to manipulate you.

4. Social and Relational Manipulation

4.1. Triangulation and Jealousy Induction

Triangulation is a manipulative tactic where the covert narcissist introduces a third party into the dynamic of your relationship. This could be an ex-partner, a friend, a coworker, or even a stranger. The goal is to create jealousy, insecurity, and competition.

Here’s how triangulation typically works:

• The narcissist praises or speaks highly of the third party
• They compare you unfavorably to this person
• They might flirt with or give attention to the third party in your presence
• They use the threat of leaving you for this person as leverage

For example, a covert narcissist might constantly talk about how great their ex was, or how their attractive coworker is always asking them out. They might also encourage you to be more like someone else they admire.

This tactic keeps you off-balance and constantly striving to prove your worth. It feeds the narcissist’s need for attention and control while eroding your self-esteem.

Unmasking the Covert Narcissist: Tactics They Use to Manipulate You
-By Som Dutt from https://embraceinnerchaos.com
Unmasking the Covert Narcissist: Tactics They Use to Manipulate You -By Som Dutt from https://embraceinnerchaos.com

4.2. One-Upmanship and Competitive Behavior

Covert narcissists often engage in subtle forms of one-upmanship and competitive behavior. Unlike overt narcissists who might blatantly boast, covert narcissists compete in more understated ways.

This might manifest as:

• Always having a similar but slightly better story to share
• Downplaying your achievements while highlighting their own
• Turning every conversation into a chance to showcase their knowledge
• Subtly undermining your successes

For instance, if you share good news about a promotion, the covert narcissist might respond with, “Oh, that reminds me of when I got promoted twice in one year at my old job.” Or if you’re excited about a new skill you’re learning, they might say, “That’s great! I actually mastered that years ago.”

This constant competition can be exhausting and demoralizing. It’s designed to keep you feeling slightly inferior and always striving for the narcissist’s approval.

4.3. Fair-Weather Friends and Conditional Support

Covert narcissists often present themselves as supportive friends or partners, but their support is highly conditional. They’re typically there for you when it benefits them or makes them look good, but absent when you truly need support.

Signs of this conditional support include:

• Being enthusiastic about your successes that reflect well on them
• Withdrawing support when you’re struggling or need help
• Only helping when others are watching
• Using their “support” as leverage later

For example, a covert narcissist might be happy to attend your work events where they can network, but unavailable when you need emotional support after a setback. They might help you move houses, but then hold it over your head for months afterward, expecting favors in return.

This inconsistent support can leave you feeling confused and undervalued. It’s a subtle way for the narcissist to maintain control and keep you dependent on their approval.

4.4. Character assassination and reputation damage

Covert narcissists are often skilled at subtle forms of character assassination and reputation damage. They might spread rumors, plant seeds of doubt about you in others’ minds, or subtly undermine your credibility.

This can take various forms:

• Sharing “concerns” about you with mutual friends or colleagues
• Making subtle jabs at your character or abilities in group settings
• Spreading misinformation or half-truths about you
• Portraying themselves as the victim of your actions

For instance, they might say things like, “I’m worried about [your name]. They’ve been acting so strange lately,” or “It’s such a shame about [your name]’s work performance. I hope they get it together soon.”

The goal is to isolate you socially and professionally, making you more dependent on the narcissist. It also feeds their need for control and allows them to maintain their image as the “good guy” while undermining you.

4.5. Playing the victim while vilifying others

Covert narcissists excel at portraying themselves as victims while simultaneously vilifying others, especially those who challenge or criticize them. This tactic serves to garner sympathy for themselves while discrediting anyone who might expose their true nature.

They might:

• Paint themselves as the target of unfair treatment or persecution
• Exaggerate or fabricate stories of being wronged
• Portray others as cruel, unreasonable, or abusive
• Use emotional manipulation to make others feel guilty for questioning them

For example, if confronted about their behavior, a covert narcissist might respond with, “I can’t believe you’d attack me like this after all I’ve done for you. You’re just like everyone else who’s tried to hurt me.”

This victim-villain narrative serves multiple purposes:

• It deflects accountability for their actions
• It elicits sympathy and support from others
• It discourages people from challenging them in the future
• It reinforces their self-image as a misunderstood, noble sufferer

By consistently playing the victim, covert narcissists create a protective shield around themselves, making it difficult for others to see through their manipulation or hold them accountable for their actions.

5. Professional and Workplace Tactics

5.1. Sabotaging Colleagues’ Success

In the workplace, covert narcissists often engage in subtle forms of sabotage to undermine their colleagues’ success. This behavior stems from their deep-seated insecurity and need to be seen as superior.

Common tactics include:

• Withholding crucial information or resources
• Giving misleading advice or directions
• Subtly undermining a coworker’s confidence before an important presentation
• Creating unnecessary obstacles or delays in projects

For example, a covert narcissist might “forget” to pass on an important email, or they might give a colleague incorrect information about a deadline. They might also plant seeds of doubt about a coworker’s abilities in conversations with superiors.

This sabotage is often so subtle that it’s hard to prove intentional wrongdoing. The narcissist maintains plausible deniability, often playing the role of the helpful colleague who’s “just trying their best.”

5.2. Taking Credit for Others’ Work

Covert narcissists are adept at claiming credit for others’ ideas and accomplishments. Unlike more overt narcissists who might boldly steal credit, covert narcissists use more subtle tactics:

• Presenting group work as their individual effort
• Downplaying others’ contributions while emphasizing their own
• Reframing others’ ideas as their own in meetings or presentations
• Taking on visible roles in successful projects, even if their actual contribution was minimal

They might say things like, “Oh yes, the team helped, but I was really the driving force behind the project,” or “I’m glad my idea inspired the group to come up with this solution.”

This behavior not only boosts the narcissist’s image but also serves to demoralize and demotivate their colleagues, further cementing the narcissist’s perceived superiority.

Unmasking the Covert Narcissist: Tactics They Use to Manipulate You-By Som Dutt from https://embraceinnerchaos.com
Unmasking the Covert Narcissist: Tactics They Use to Manipulate You-By Som Dutt from https://embraceinnerchaos.com

5.3. Subtle Undermining and Backhanded Compliments

In professional settings, covert narcissists often use subtle undermining tactics and backhanded compliments to erode their colleagues’ confidence and standing.

Examples of subtle undermining include:

• Pointing out minor mistakes in public settings
• Questioning someone’s expertise in front of others
• Offering unsolicited “constructive criticism” that’s more critical than constructive

Backhanded compliments in the workplace might sound like:

• “Wow, your presentation was actually pretty good. You’ve really improved!”
• “I’m impressed you managed to finish that project on time. It must have been challenging for someone at your level.”
• “You’re so lucky to have gotten that promotion. It’s great that the company values diversity.”

These comments are designed to sound positive on the surface while subtly undermining the recipient’s confidence and accomplishments.

5.4. Covert bullying and undermining colleagues

Covert narcissists often engage in subtle forms of workplace bullying that can be difficult to identify and address. This behavior is designed to assert dominance and control while maintaining a façade of professionalism.

Tactics might include:

• Excluding certain colleagues from important meetings or social events
• Spreading gossip or rumors
• Using body language or facial expressions to make others feel uncomfortable
• Engaging in passive-aggressive behavior, like ignoring emails or giving the silent treatment

For example, a covert narcissist might consistently interrupt or talk over a particular colleague in meetings, or they might make subtle digs at someone’s competence in front of clients or superiors.

This behavior creates a toxic work environment and can significantly impact the mental health and job performance of those targeted.

5.5. Manipulating supervisors and playing office politics

Covert narcissists are often skilled at manipulating their superiors and navigating office politics to their advantage. They may use a combination of charm, strategic information control, and subtle manipulation to curry favor with those in power.

Tactics might include:

• Flattering supervisors and those in positions of authority
• Strategically sharing or withholding information to make themselves look good
• Aligning themselves with influential colleagues
• Subtly discrediting potential rivals or threats to their position

For instance, a covert narcissist might go out of their way to do small favors for their boss, creating a sense of indebtedness. They might also carefully curate the information they share, ensuring that their successes are highlighted while downplaying any failures or mistakes.

This manipulation of office politics allows the covert narcissist to advance their career and maintain a position of influence, often at the expense of more qualified or deserving colleagues.

6. Digital and Technological Manipulation

6.1. Curated Online Personas

In the digital age, covert narcissists have found new avenues for manipulation through carefully curated online personas. Social media platforms provide the perfect stage for them to present an idealized version of themselves to the world.

Key aspects of their curated online personas include:

• Posting carefully selected photos that portray a perfect life
• Sharing inspirational quotes or “humble” brags about their achievements
• Engaging in performative acts of kindness or activism for online praise
• Subtly fishing for compliments through self-deprecating posts

For example, they might post a photo of themselves “working hard” at a luxurious resort, or share a story about how they “reluctantly” accepted a prestigious award. These posts are designed to elicit admiration and envy while maintaining an appearance of humility.

This curated persona often bears little resemblance to their real-life behavior, creating a stark contrast that can be confusing and frustrating for those who know them personally.

6.2. Fishing for Sympathy and Attention

Covert narcissists often use digital platforms to fish for sympathy and attention. They may engage in behaviors like:

• Vague posting or “sadfishing” (posting about emotional problems to gain sympathy)
• Sharing exaggerated or fabricated stories of hardship
• Posting about health issues or personal struggles
• Using social media to subtly criticize or shame others who “don’t support them enough”

For instance, they might post something like, “Going through a really tough time right now… I guess you find out who your real friends are,” or “Another sleepless night… sometimes I wonder if anyone truly cares.”

These posts are designed to elicit concerned responses and offers of support, feeding the narcissist’s need for attention and validation.

6.3. Cyberbullying and Online Harassment

While covert narcissists may maintain a positive public image, they often engage in cyberbullying and online harassment behind the scenes. This allows them to attack others while maintaining plausible deniability.

Tactics might include:

• Leaving subtle, passive-aggressive comments on others’ posts
• Creating fake accounts to troll or harass others anonymously
• Engaging in online arguments or debates with the intent to belittle others
• Spreading rumors or sharing private information online

For example, they might leave a comment like, “Wow, you’re so brave to post a photo without filters!” or use a fake account to criticize someone’s work or appearance.

This online behavior allows the covert narcissist to express their aggression and superiority while maintaining their curated positive image.

6.4. Digital Stalking and Surveillance

Covert narcissists may engage in digital stalking and surveillance to maintain control and gather information. This behavior can range from excessive monitoring of social media accounts to more invasive forms of digital spying.

Examples include:

• Constantly checking a partner’s online activity and interactions
• Using tracking apps or spyware on a partner’s devices
• Creating fake social media accounts to monitor others
• Hacking into email or social media accounts

This digital stalking serves multiple purposes:

• It feeds their need for control and information
• It allows them to manipulate situations based on the information they gather
• It provides ammunition for future gaslighting or manipulation

The covert nature of this surveillance can make it particularly insidious, as victims may be unaware they’re being monitored.

6.5. Creating false online personas and identities

Covert narcissists sometimes create false online personas or identities to further their manipulation tactics. These fake identities serve various purposes:

• Gathering information about others without detection
• Providing “independent” validation for their claims or actions
• Harassing or manipulating others anonymously
• Creating a false sense of popularity or support for themselves

For instance, they might create a fake social media account to befriend their partner’s friends and gather information. Or they might use multiple accounts to leave positive comments on their own posts, creating an illusion of popularity.

These false identities allow the covert narcissist to manipulate perceptions and control narratives in ways that wouldn’t be possible with their real identity. It’s a digital extension of their real-life tendency to present false or exaggerated versions of themselves.

Unmasking the Covert Narcissist: Tactics They Use to Manipulate You-By Som Dutt from https://embraceinnerchaos.com
Unmasking the Covert Narcissist: Tactics They Use to Manipulate You-By Som Dutt from https://embraceinnerchaos.com

7. Time and Space Manipulation

7.1. Chronic Lateness and Time-Wasting

Covert narcissists often manipulate time as a way to assert control and demonstrate their perceived importance. Chronic lateness is a common manifestation of this behavior.

Key aspects of this tactic include:

• Consistently arriving late to appointments or events
• Making others wait for them without apology
• Offering elaborate excuses for their tardiness
• Expecting others to be punctual while disregarding time themselves

This behavior sends the message that their time is more valuable than others’, and that they’re above adhering to societal norms of punctuality.

Additionally, covert narcissists may engage in time-wasting behaviors such as:

• Dragging out simple tasks or conversations
• Creating unnecessary work or complications
• Procrastinating on important tasks that affect others

These tactics serve to frustrate and control others, reinforcing the narcissist’s sense of power and importance.

7.2. Rush Tactics and Manufactured Urgency

On the flip side of chronic lateness, covert narcissists may also use rush tactics and manufactured urgency to manipulate others. This involves creating artificial time pressures to force quick decisions or actions that benefit the narcissist.

Examples include:

• Springing last-minute requests or deadlines on others
• Insisting on immediate responses to non-urgent matters
• Creating false emergencies to demand attention or favors
• Using time pressure to prevent others from thinking critically or seeking advice

These tactics are designed to keep others off-balance and compliant. By manipulating the perception of time and urgency, the covert narcissist maintains control over situations and people.

7.3. Procrastination as a Control Tactic

Procrastination can be a powerful tool in the covert narcissist’s arsenal of manipulation tactics. By deliberately delaying tasks or decisions, they can:

• Create anxiety and frustration in others
• Force others to take on their responsibilities
• Maintain control over timelines and outcomes
• Avoid accountability by claiming they “didn’t have enough time”

For example, a covert narcissist might wait until the last minute to complete their part of a group project, forcing others to either pick up the slack or risk a poor outcome. Or they might delay making important decisions, keeping others in a state of uncertainty and dependence.

This procrastination is often selective – the narcissist may be quite prompt and efficient when it serves their interests, but chronically late or unprepared when it doesn’t.

7.4. Invasion of Personal Space

Covert narcissists may subtly invade others’ personal space as a form of control and boundary violation. This can manifest in various ways:

• Standing too close during conversations
• Touching others without permission (e.g., a hand on the shoulder)
• Entering private spaces without invitation
• Borrowing personal items without asking

These invasions might seem minor, but they serve to assert dominance and make others feel uncomfortable or violated. The covert narcissist might claim ignorance if confronted, saying they’re just being “friendly” or “didn’t realize” they were making someone uncomfortable.

In digital spaces, this might involve:

• Excessive messaging or calling
• Expecting immediate responses to communications
• Monitoring online activity or demanding access to private accounts

These behaviors blur the lines of personal boundaries, making it difficult for others to maintain their sense of privacy and autonomy.

7.5. Using Body Language to Intimidate

Covert narcissists often use subtle body language cues to intimidate or assert dominance over others. These non-verbal signals can be powerful tools of manipulation, as they’re often processed subconsciously by the receiver.

Examples of intimidating body language include:

• Maintaining prolonged, intense eye contact
• Invading personal space (as mentioned above)
• Using a patronizing or condescending tone of voice
• Adopting closed-off or aggressive postures (crossed arms, hands on hips)
• Subtle facial expressions of disgust or disdain

For instance, a covert narcissist might stand over someone while they’re seated, or use their physical presence to block exits during conversations. They might also use dismissive gestures or eye rolls to undermine others while maintaining plausible deniability.

These body language tactics are designed to make others feel small, insecure, or inferior, reinforcing the narcissist’s sense of control and superiority.

8. Intellectual and Cultural Manipulation

8.1. Pseudo-Intellectualism and Faux Expertise

Covert narcissists often present themselves as intellectual authorities or experts in various fields, even when their knowledge is superficial or inaccurate. This pseudo-intellectualism serves to impress others and maintain their image of superiority.

Tactics might include:

• Using complex vocabulary or jargon incorrectly
• Making sweeping generalizations about complex topics

The Psychological Toll of Covert Narcissism

Covert narcissism takes an insidious toll on the emotional and mental well-being of its victims. This form of manipulation is often subtle, making it challenging to detect and confront. Victims of covert narcissists frequently experience psychological trauma, prolonged exposure to harmful patterns, and a distorted perception of reality. These psychological effects can lead to significant emotional turmoil, creating an environment where victims doubt their own sense of reality. Mental health professionals emphasize that understanding these covert tactics is a critical step in the healing process.

One of the most devastating effects of covert narcissism is the erosion of emotional stability in intimate relationships. The constant use of manipulative behaviors, such as guilt-tripping tactics and gaslighting techniques, destabilizes the victim’s self-esteem. Victims often internalize negative self-talk, blaming themselves for the covert narcissist’s abusive behavior. Addressing these issues requires therapeutic interventions that focus on rebuilding self-worth and recognizing the impact of psychological manipulation.

Exploring Emotional Manipulation in Relationships

Covert narcissists employ a variety of sneaky tactics to gain control in personal relationships. A common tactic involves exploiting feelings of guilt, which serves as a powerful weapon in their arsenal. Guilt manipulation in abusive relationships is particularly destructive, as it often leaves victims feeling trapped and emotionally drained. These tactics create a cycle of manipulation that can be difficult to break without professional support.

Fear of rejection and abandonment are often exploited by covert narcissists to maintain control over their victims. This deep-seated fear is manipulated to create a power imbalance, where the victim’s emotional response becomes a tool for the narcissist’s gain. Mental health disorders, such as narcissistic personality disorder, often underpin these behaviors. Understanding the dynamics of guilt-inducing behaviors and learning to recognize signs of narcissistic behavior are essential steps in overcoming these challenges.

The Role of Gaslighting in Emotional Control

Gaslighting is a hallmark tactic of covert narcissists, used to distort the victim’s perception of reality and reinforce their control. Attempts at gaslighting often involve subtle manipulation tactics designed to make victims question their memories and judgments. For example, covert narcissists might use digital gaslighting by altering messages or denying online interactions to confuse their target. This form of gaslighting behaviors erodes trust and intensifies the emotional toll on the victim.

Exposure to gaslighting can result in significant psychological abuse, leaving victims unable to trust their own sense of reality. This form of manipulation frequently appears in both personal and professional relationships, where high-conflict personalities thrive on creating confusion. Addressing these insidious tactics requires a deep dive into the psychology of narcissistic manipulation, equipping victims with the tools to regain control and clarity.

Trauma Bonding: The Cycle of Manipulation

Trauma bonding is a destructive cycle that covert narcissists use to maintain their influence over victims. This form of manipulation alternates between affection and cruelty, creating an addictive pattern of emotional highs and lows. Victims often feel a sense of guilt for wanting to leave the relationship, further entrenching the bond. This cycle of manipulation reinforces the covert narcissist’s power dynamics, leaving victims feeling trapped and emotionally dependent.

Breaking free from trauma bonding requires a keen understanding of its underlying dynamics. Mental health professionals advocate for cognitive-behavioral strategies to help victims identify and disrupt harmful patterns. These therapeutic interventions not only promote emotional stability but also lay the groundwork for healthier relationships in the future. Victims of narcissistic abuse must recognize the signs of trauma bonding to begin the process of recovery and reclaim their autonomy.

The Impact of Covert Narcissism on Professional Relationships

In professional settings, covert narcissists often exploit power dynamics to manipulate colleagues and superiors. They rely on narcissist control tactics, such as subtle undermining and strategic procrastination, to maintain their influence. These behaviors contribute to a toxic workplace environment, where victims face constant emotional abuse and struggle to establish mutual understanding.

Covert narcissists’ manipulative behaviors in the workplace often include engaging in the demand-withdraw pattern. This involves creating false emergencies or withholding critical information, forcing others into positions of disadvantage. Victims may experience negative feelings of inadequacy or frustration, further undermining their emotional health. Mental health professionals highlight the importance of addressing these behaviors through legal proceedings or supportive newsletters that raise awareness of covert narcissism’s destructive effects in the workplace.

Leveraging Therapeutic Interventions for Recovery

Overcoming the devastating effects of covert narcissism requires a comprehensive approach to recovery. Therapeutic interventions, such as cognitive-behavioral strategies and trauma-focused therapies, are vital in addressing the emotional abuse caused by narcissistic manipulation. Victims often benefit from working with a health care provider who can tailor treatment plans to their specific needs.

Healing from psychological trauma involves understanding the manipulative relationship dynamics that perpetuate abuse. By focusing on emotional health and addressing feelings of guilt, victims can begin the process of reclaiming their self-worth. Support systems, including online resources and supportive newsletters, play a crucial role in providing the knowledge and encouragement needed to navigate the healing process. Coping with guilt after narcissistic abuse is a journey that requires patience, resilience, and professional guidance.

Identifying High-Conflict Personalities in Relationships

High-conflict personalities, such as covert narcissists, exhibit a range of behaviors that undermine personal relationships. These individuals often manipulate through guilt as a control mechanism, creating a sense of guilt that fosters emotional dependency. Recognizing these harmful patterns is essential to breaking free from manipulative relationships.

The emotional toll of high-conflict personalities extends to both intimate and professional spheres. Their use of narcissistic guilt-tripping tactics leads to prolonged exposure to toxic guilt, which erodes emotional stability. Mental health professionals recommend early intervention to mitigate the devastating effects on the victim’s well-being.

The Connection Between Emotional Predators and Trauma Bonding

Emotional predators, like covert narcissists, rely on the cycle of trauma bonding to maintain control over their victims. By alternating between affection and abuse, they create a dynamic that fosters a deep-seated fear of rejection. Victims often experience a fragile self-esteem, making it challenging to recognize and escape the abuse cycle.

Understanding the psychology of narcissistic guilt and trauma bonding is key to recovery. Therapeutic interventions that address the emotional and psychological damage inflicted by these predators are crucial. Victims are encouraged to seek support from mental health professionals to rebuild their sense of self-worth and establish healthier relationships.

The Destructive Effects of Guilt in Narcissistic Relationships

Guilt is a powerful tool used by covert narcissists to manipulate and control their victims. This emotional weapon often manifests as guilt-inducing behaviors that leave victims feeling trapped and disempowered. The insidious form of guilt manipulation creates a sense of obligation, making it difficult for victims to assert their boundaries.

Mental health professionals emphasize the importance of addressing feelings of guilt in narcissistic relationships. Coping with guilt after narcissistic abuse requires a combination of therapeutic strategies and supportive resources. Victims must recognize that guilt is a form of manipulation and not a reflection of their worth or actions.

Recognizing Digital Manipulation by Covert Narcissists

Digital manipulation is another tactic used by covert narcissists to control their victims. Online gaslighting and digital gaslighting involve altering or denying online interactions to create confusion and undermine the victim’s sense of reality. These forms of manipulation often occur in both personal and professional relationships.

Exposure to gaslighting behaviors in digital spaces can exacerbate the emotional toll on victims. Recognizing these sneaky tactics is the first step towards reclaiming control and rebuilding emotional stability. Mental health professionals recommend maintaining detailed records of interactions to counteract the manipulative narratives of covert narcissists.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Are the Subtle Manipulation Tactics Used by Covert Narcissists to Control Their Victims?

Covert narcissists often employ subtle manipulation tactics that go unnoticed until their impact becomes deeply ingrained in the victim’s psyche. One common method is gaslighting, where the narcissist twists or denies reality to make their victim doubt their perception of events. This tactic erodes the victim’s self-trust and fosters dependence on the narcissist’s version of reality. Emotional predators of this kind also exploit vulnerabilities by using guilt-tripping tactics—an insidious form of manipulation that frames their victim as perpetually at fault, reinforcing a sense of guilt and unworthiness.

Another hallmark of covert narcissism is their ability to weaponize the victim’s emotions, often provoking an emotional response and then labeling it as overreaction. Such psychological manipulation gradually destabilizes the victim’s mental well-being. Mental Health America emphasizes that recognizing these tactics is crucial for breaking free from their grasp and seeking healthier relationships.

How Does Gaslighting by Covert Narcissists Affect a Victim’s Perception of Reality?

Gaslighting is a cornerstone of the covert narcissist’s toolkit and profoundly impacts a victim’s sense of reality. This manipulation tactic involves the deliberate distortion of facts or outright denial of events to make the victim question their memory and judgment. Over time, victims may start doubting their own recollection and rely on the narcissist’s interpretation, creating a power imbalance that benefits the manipulator.

The emotional toll of such manipulation can lead to devastating effects on the victim’s self-esteem and emotional stability. Victims often experience prolonged exposure to psychological abuse, which fosters feelings of confusion, self-doubt, and fear of rejection. Psychology Today highlights that these effects can linger even after the victim exits the abusive relationship, necessitating therapeutic interventions to rebuild their mental health.

What Are Common Tactics Used by Covert Narcissists to Elicit Guilt in Their Victims?

Covert narcissists frequently employ guilt as a weapon to manipulate and control their victims. One such tactic is the use of toxic guilt, where they frame themselves as the perpetual victim to elicit feelings of responsibility and obligation from others. By presenting their needs and desires as paramount, they create a dynamic where the victim’s self-worth becomes tied to satisfying the narcissist’s demands.

These manipulative behaviors often involve guilt-inducing phrases like, “After all I’ve done for you” or “You’re so selfish.” Such statements reinforce a narrative of inadequacy and compel the victim to comply with the narcissist’s wishes to avoid further guilt. According to BetterHelp, understanding and recognizing these patterns is critical for breaking free from the cycle of manipulation and reclaiming emotional autonomy.

How Do Covert Narcissists Exploit Power Imbalances in Intimate Relationships?

In intimate relationships, covert narcissists exploit power dynamics to maintain control and assert dominance. They often engage in subtle manipulation tactics such as withholding affection, creating dependency, and using emotional blackmail to keep their partners in a state of compliance. The imbalance is perpetuated by undermining the victim’s confidence through negative self-talk and psychological manipulation.

The cycle of manipulation fosters a toxic environment where the victim feels trapped and unable to voice their concerns without facing retaliation or further emotional abuse. This pattern not only impacts the victim’s mental health condition but also undermines their ability to form healthier relationships in the future. Verywell Mind notes that recognizing these tactics and seeking support from mental health professionals are vital steps toward breaking free from the abusive cycle.

What Are the Signs of Narcissistic Guilt-Tripping Tactics?

Narcissistic guilt-tripping tactics are characterized by the covert manipulation of the victim’s emotions to achieve compliance. These tactics often involve shifting blame onto the victim, framing them as inconsiderate or neglectful. A common example is when the narcissist expresses exaggerated disappointment or uses phrases designed to evoke a sense of guilt, such as “You never care about my feelings.”

This form of manipulation creates a sense of obligation in the victim, often leading to feelings of inadequacy and an increased willingness to appease the narcissist. Healthline underscores that these tactics are often subtle yet devastating, eroding the victim’s self-esteem over time and making them increasingly vulnerable to further abuse.

How Does Psychological Manipulation by Covert Narcissists Affect Emotional Health?

Psychological manipulation by covert narcissists takes a significant toll on the victim’s emotional health. This manipulation often involves insidious tactics such as exploiting insecurities, provoking negative feelings, and dismissing the victim’s emotions. Over time, these behaviors can lead to a deep-seated fear of abandonment and a fragile sense of self-worth.

Victims frequently struggle with feelings of helplessness and confusion, which can evolve into long-term psychological trauma if left unaddressed. Seeking therapeutic interventions and building mutual understanding in supportive relationships can help victims recover and regain emotional stability. National Institute of Mental Health emphasizes the importance of addressing these impacts to foster long-term healing.

What Is Trauma Bonding, and How Does It Occur in Relationships With Covert Narcissists?

Trauma bonding occurs when a victim forms an emotional attachment to their abuser, often as a result of intermittent reinforcement of affection and abuse. Covert narcissists foster this bond by alternating between kindness and cruelty, creating a cycle of manipulation that keeps the victim invested in the relationship despite its harmful nature. This dynamic perpetuates a sense of dependency and loyalty in the victim.

The abusive relationship’s unpredictable nature leads the victim to focus on the occasional positive moments, ignoring the broader pattern of harm. Psych Central explains that breaking free from trauma bonding requires acknowledging the manipulative behaviors and seeking professional support to rebuild self-esteem and establish healthier boundaries.

How Do Covert Narcissists Use Emotional Predation to Manipulate Their Victims?

Covert narcissists use emotional predation by targeting their victim’s vulnerabilities and exploiting them for personal gain. This manipulation often involves creating scenarios that provoke emotional turmoil, only to position themselves as the victim or savior. Such sneaky tactics are designed to erode the victim’s emotional stability and establish dominance in the relationship.

By using the victim’s emotional responses against them, covert narcissists maintain control and ensure their needs remain the priority. American Psychological Association highlights that understanding these tactics is essential for recognizing abusive behavior and fostering resilience against manipulation.

How Can Victims Recognize and Cope With the Emotional Toll of Covert Narcissistic Abuse?

Recognizing the emotional toll of covert narcissistic abuse involves identifying patterns of subtle manipulation and psychological control. Common scenarios include constant criticism, shifting blame, and creating a sense of dependency. Victims often feel trapped, experiencing chronic stress, anxiety, and low self-esteem as a result of prolonged exposure to abusive behaviors.

Coping with these effects requires a combination of self-awareness, support networks, and therapeutic interventions. The National Domestic Violence Hotline advises victims to prioritize their mental health by setting boundaries and seeking professional guidance to navigate the complexities of recovery.

How Do Narcissistic Abuse Victims Heal From Psychological Trauma?

Healing from the psychological trauma of narcissistic abuse involves addressing the deep-seated wounds caused by prolonged exposure to manipulation and emotional abuse. Victims often struggle with negative self-talk and a distorted sense of reality, making it crucial to reframe their experiences through therapy and self-compassion. Cognitive-behavioral strategies can help victims rebuild their confidence and regain control over their emotional health.

Establishing supportive relationships and engaging in activities that promote self-worth are also key components of the healing process. Mayo Clinic emphasizes the importance of therapeutic interventions tailored to the unique challenges faced by narcissistic abuse survivors, enabling them to recover and thrive in healthier environments.

How Do Covert Narcissists Use Digital Gaslighting to Manipulate Their Victims?

Digital gaslighting is a modern tactic employed by covert narcissists to manipulate their victims. This form of gaslighting involves using online platforms to distort facts, deny previous statements, or fabricate new narratives, leaving the victim doubting their memory and perception. Covert narcissists exploit the digital realm to erase digital footprints, send conflicting messages, or publicly question the victim’s integrity.

This manipulation often creates a sense of confusion and emotional instability in the victim, further cementing the narcissist’s control. According to Cyberpsychology, Behavior, and Social Networking, recognizing digital gaslighting is crucial for maintaining a healthy sense of reality and seeking protective measures against online manipulation.

What Are the Emotional and Psychological Effects of Prolonged Exposure to Covert Narcissists?

Prolonged exposure to covert narcissists can lead to significant emotional and psychological distress. Victims often develop chronic stress, anxiety, and symptoms of depression due to the relentless cycle of manipulation and abuse. The impact on relationships and personal well-being is profound, as victims struggle to maintain emotional stability and self-worth.

The insidious nature of covert narcissism leaves victims feeling isolated and trapped, which exacerbates their emotional turmoil. WebMD emphasizes that addressing these harmful patterns through therapy and support networks is essential for recovering and regaining control over one’s mental health.

How Does Fear of Abandonment Drive Manipulative Behaviors in Covert Narcissists?

Fear of abandonment is a driving force behind many manipulative behaviors exhibited by covert narcissists. This deep-seated fear often manifests in tactics like guilt-tripping, gaslighting, and creating dependency in their victims. Covert narcissists use these tactics to ensure that their victims remain emotionally invested and unable to leave the relationship.

The manipulator’s fragile self-esteem and fear of rejection fuel their need to maintain control at all costs, often at the expense of their victim’s mental health. National Alliance on Mental Illness highlights that understanding the root of these behaviors can empower victims to break free and establish boundaries that promote healthier relationships.

How Do Covert Narcissists Use Constructive Criticism as a Tool for Manipulation?

Covert narcissists often disguise their manipulation through constructive criticism, which may appear helpful but is designed to undermine the victim’s confidence. By framing their comments as “advice,” they subtly highlight flaws and insecurities, making the victim feel inadequate and reliant on the narcissist’s approval.

This tactic not only damages the victim’s self-esteem but also reinforces the power imbalance in the relationship. Harvard Business Review points out that recognizing the manipulative intent behind such criticism is essential for maintaining emotional health and fostering mutual understanding in relationships.

What Role Does Toxic Guilt Play in the Cycle of Manipulation by Covert Narcissists?

Toxic guilt is a key tool in the covert narcissist’s arsenal for perpetuating the cycle of manipulation. By inducing feelings of guilt in their victims, narcissists create a dynamic where the victim feels compelled to prioritize the narcissist’s needs above their own. This tactic often involves exaggerating personal sacrifices or framing the victim’s actions as hurtful or selfish.

The psychological manipulation of guilt not only maintains the narcissist’s control but also deepens the victim’s emotional dependence. GoodTherapy explains that addressing these dynamics is critical for breaking free from manipulative relationships and reclaiming one’s sense of self.

How Does Covert Narcissism Differ From Overt Narcissism in Manipulation Tactics?

While both covert and overt narcissists engage in manipulative behaviors, their approaches differ significantly. Covert narcissists rely on subtle, insidious tactics like guilt-tripping and passive-aggressiveness, whereas overt narcissists are more likely to use direct and grandiose methods such as public humiliation or overt threats. Covert narcissists often appear humble or self-effacing, masking their manipulative intent.

Understanding these distinctions can help victims identify and address the specific tactics used in their relationships. The Cleveland Clinic emphasizes the importance of tailoring therapeutic interventions to the unique challenges posed by covert narcissistic abuse.

How Do Covert Narcissists Leverage the Victim’s Emotional Responses to Maintain Control?

Covert narcissists are adept at provoking emotional responses in their victims to maintain control. They may use subtle insults, emotional withdrawal, or calculated comments to elicit reactions like anger, sadness, or guilt. Once the victim reacts, the narcissist shifts the blame, portraying the victim as unstable or overly sensitive.

This manipulation not only reinforces the victim’s feelings of inadequacy but also serves to justify the narcissist’s behavior. Psychology Today highlights that recognizing and managing emotional triggers is vital for breaking the cycle of manipulation and fostering emotional resilience.

How Can Narcissistic Abuse Survivors Rebuild Their Sense of Self-Worth?

Rebuilding self-worth after narcissistic abuse involves addressing the deep emotional scars left by prolonged manipulation. Survivors often struggle with feelings of guilt, shame, and self-doubt, making it essential to reframe their experiences through therapy and self-compassion. Engaging in activities that promote self-expression and reconnecting with supportive communities can aid in recovery.

Establishing boundaries and focusing on personal growth are also key steps in the healing process. The National Center for PTSD underscores that therapeutic interventions tailored to the survivor’s needs can help restore confidence and foster healthier relationships moving forward.

What Are Effective Strategies for Coping With the Manipulative Behaviors of Covert Narcissists?

Coping with the manipulative behaviors of covert narcissists requires a combination of self-awareness, boundary-setting, and support from mental health professionals. Identifying patterns of manipulation, such as gaslighting or guilt-tripping, is the first step in reducing their impact. Victims should prioritize their emotional health by seeking therapy and building a strong support network.

Learning to respond assertively and avoiding emotional engagement can also minimize the narcissist’s influence. Counseling Today emphasizes that empowering oneself through education and self-care is crucial for maintaining emotional stability and fostering resilience against future manipulation.


About the Author :

Som Dutt, Top writer in Philosophy & Psychology on Medium.com. I make people Think, Relate, Feel & Move. Let's Embrace Inner Chaos and Appreciate Deep, Novel & Heavy Thoughts.

Leave a reply:

Your email address will not be published.